Gotta go with Linda Sweet on the right.
I like normal looking women, the one's you can encounter in streets and would never guess they're into that sort of thing. Pale/redheads get instant-first preference, too.
If I was fucking her by myself? Fuck her like I would a girlfriend: take her back home, chill atmosphere, very measured, making out for ages (redhead weakness after all); voyeuristic. But really take my time for anal exploration considering her incredible abilities: prep, enemas, eating her out, fisting/stretching/prolapse, toys, speculum, etc. Certainly in a Buttman-esque breaking the 4th wall style. Reveling in how amazing assholes and legs/feet are. Would be glad to spend an afternoon filming candidly for personal use, breaks throughout. This scenario would have various clit/vag stimulation orgasms on her part throughout, and end in her swallowing cum.